How Landlords Charge For Repairs And Redecoration

  • News
  • How Landlords Charge For Repairs And Redecoration

REPAIRS

The tenancy agreement confirms tenants must return the property in the same condition as the start of the tenancy. As general rule damage by a tenant must be negligence. If damage is made by a tenant by negligence, then you can claim. If it is malicious you can claim. They can make good the redecoration. However, they must consider the fair wear and tear.

RICS, ARLA, NAEA and Asset Skills have provided the following guidance. This gives the lifespan of items in a rented property for redecoration. This can help in determining what allowance to make for wear and tear. This guidance is also used by the DPS (Please see our previous article relating to Tenants Deposit Protection, click here) in the event of a dispute over the deductions:

Decoration Repairs

Hall, landing, stairs – between 2 to 3 years

Living Rooms – approximately 4 years

Dining Rooms – approximately 6 years

Kitchen and bathrooms – between 2 to 3 years

Bedrooms – approximately 5 years

Carpets

Budget carpet 3-5 years Medium quality 5-10 years

Top quality up to 20 years

Appliances Repairs

Washing machine 3-5 years Cookers/ Ovens/ Hobs 4-6 years

Fridges 5-8 years

In their “Summary of the principles of dealing with Deposits, Disputes and Damages” leaflet, ARLA say:

  1. Minor damage to an item, a small to medium stain or mark on a carpet or mattress: £15-£35. A small to medium sized chip or mark, scratch or burn on a kitchen worktop: £5 – £25.
  2. In the case that these items need replacing in their entirety we will claim any cost. He may have to apportion the figures. They must show that the charges are reasonable.

It is important to fill in any holes in the walls. They must then redecorate the whole room not just one wall. They must fix or replace any broken items. If any rooms have been painted a different colour, they must be repainted the original colour.

How much should you claim?

Many landlords believe that the property should be returned to them in the same condition at the start of the tenancy. Deductions are often claimed from the deposit in minor damage that should be expected in normal use of the property. Landlords might want to replace items in the property which are coming to the end of their natural life, such as old washing machine where the door handle has broken during the tenancy.

The house of laws define wear and tear as “reasonable use of the premises by the tenant and the ordinary operation of natural forces”.

The word “reasonable” can be interpreted differently, depending on the type of property and who occupies it. It is an established legal principle that the landlord is not entitled to charge tenants for the full cost of having any part of their property, or any fixture or fitting, put back to the condition it was at the start of the tenancy. The landlord should therefore keep in mind that the tenants deposit is not to be used like an insurance policy where you might get “full replacement value” or “new for old”. The landlord also have a duty to act reasonably and not to claim more than necessary to make any loss.

An example of how this can be calculated is as follows;

  1. Cost of similar replacement
  2. Age of existing item
  3. Average use or lifespan of the item
  4. Residual lifespan of the item calculated as follows;

C – B

  1. Appreciation of the value rate as calculated;

A/C

  1. Reasonable apportionment to tenant as calculated;

D X E

An example of this for a carpet replacement would be as follows;

A = £500

B = 2 years

C = 5 years

D = 5 years minus 2 years = 3 years

E = £500/5 years = £100 per year

F = 3 Years X E = £300.00

Please note this would be the reasonable view when coming to an adjudication at one of the schemes. However, it is not always the appropriate approach. It can differ from case to case.

The landlord cannot do betterment.

Betterment is when the landlord is claiming the costs of making the property better than when the tenants originally moved in. This is not allowed under any of the deposit schemes. It includes for example, above expectation of tenants to return the property cleaner than when they moved in, as well as replacing old goods, fixtures or fittings with new or better, or redecorating the property at a higher standard than at the start of the tenancy.

However, landlords are entitled in the event that the property was fully professionally cleaned when the tenants first moved in to expect it to be fully professionally cleaned when they move out. Obviously, a residual lifespan needs to be taken into account so tenants aren’t left with the full cost of replacing furniture that can only have use for a couple of years as outlined above.

What would be a reasonable clauses?

To replace any items at the end of the tenancy and provide new. This is usually seen in student tenancies and relates to such items as mattress protectors. Any clause that receipts to transfer and obligation of the landlord onto the tenant.

Clauses allowing the landlord to enter the property at any time without prior notice.

What do the schemes take into account when dealing with adjudication?

It is almost impossible to understand how deposit schemes work as every Government backed scheme has a different way of dealing with it. However, there should be guidelines for adjudicators in relation to the deposit.

We would think the most common factors of a particular decision are as follows;

Length of tenancy.

The longer the tenancy the more natural wear. Common sense but think for example how much of a wear the carpet in your own home is after one or two years then consider it at the beginning of the tenancy. Take this all into account before claiming for repairs.

The number and age of the occupiers.

The more bedrooms and the more occupants the higher the wear and tear should be expected in all the common parts. For instance passages, stairs, bathrooms, kitchens etc. If you are letting to a family with children that needs to be taken into account too. Scuffs and scraps are unavoidable in normal family day life. A property occupied by a single person should see far less wear and tear than a family of four.

Wear and tear VS actual damage.

When is it no longer normal wear, ie damage and in need of repairs? Breaking something is not wear and tear. This can mean it should be replaced or repaired. Light marks on the carpet may be viewed as unavoidable. On the other hand damage such as nail varnish spilt on the floor or iron burns would occur due to negligence and would see the tenant liable for the repair. You need to consider whether the item has been damaged or worn out through natural use rather than negligence. It is a judgement call.

Quality and condition.

Consider the quality of the item at the start of the tenancy and what is originally cost to provide. It would be unreasonable for a landlord to provide cheap and flimsy bedroom furniture and then blame the tenants for damage through normal usage. Other considerations take into account the quality of fabric and the property itself. Many new blinds tend not to be quite as robust as older properties or conversations. Walls, partitions and internal painted surfaces tend to be thinner and therefore likely to have more stress. Particularly in higher footfall areas of the property. This inevitably means that there is a greater need for redecoration at the end of the tenancy.

CHARGES

This only relates to any breach of the tenancy agreement. The terms and conditions include the charges applicable.

If you are currently looking for landlord insurance why not contact our sister company iInsure 365 in this regard. They are specialists in the market and happy to give you a quote. Call them on 01273 827090 or enquiries@iinsure365.co.uk

See all News Posts
google-review Review
Tegan
Tegan
17:30 22 Feb 24
Have been very accommodating and helpful when calling agents. They have been very helpful in being able to secure a house for students.
TheFlyingCrocodile
TheFlyingCrocodile
16:42 21 Feb 24
Went above and beyond to get things sorted for me
Brittany Stace
Brittany Stace
11:18 24 Jan 24
Harringtons have been incredibly helpful and supportive of us as new renters and they have been super efficient in getting all of the documents sent through and signed in such a short period of time. Thank you!
Georgie Prebble
Georgie Prebble
20:36 05 Jan 24
Jade Innes
Jade Innes
10:24 04 Jan 24
So far the service has been good. The staff are very friendly and quick to respond to any questions and requests.
Polly Smith
Polly Smith
11:17 28 Dec 23
we chose this letting agents as they chose a good bills company that is much cheaper than other agents. When viewing houses the staff were very friendly and have been very helpful in answering our questions and making the process as easy as possible.
Emma Howe
Emma Howe
16:06 14 Nov 23
I would rate Harringtons Lettings a 5/5. Very lovely on the phone and very quick and easy to communicate with via email. Any problems have been resolved in no time at all. So far so good!I found Harringtons via Rightmove.
Akwisitions Feedback
Akwisitions Feedback
16:25 30 Oct 23
Very responsive and super helpful throughout the process. Highly recommended!
Chloe Ballard
Chloe Ballard
17:28 02 Oct 23
Although I have only been renting with Harringtons for a short period of time, I have had nothing but a positive experience. From viewing to admin updates. The admin team especially are very polite and quick to respond and I have no doubt that the rest of my tenancy will run smoothly. I would recommend to anyone considering renting in brighton.
Matthew Ball
Matthew Ball
11:46 19 Sep 23
Professional communication with tenant although entirely impersonal. There was a bigger disconnect in their communication with the landlord in most cases, which seemed to be either slow or non-existent (discovered after contacting the landlord directly).Property was full of spider webs on day 1 despite apparently being professionally cleaned. Took a day off of work to clean it on move out day, leaving it cleaner than when it received but still had to pay part of the deposit for professional cleaning.It has been a while since I have rented, but I'll avoid letting agencies completely now if this is anything close to the average renting experience.
Ronan SK
Ronan SK
12:38 12 Sep 23
Great professionalism/communciation from the start up until the end of my tenancy. Definitely set the standards for what agencies should be like. Highly recommend to those within Brighton.
Daniel Sutton
Daniel Sutton
10:29 24 Aug 23
I have rented with Harringtons Lettings before and have always found the agents to be quick, efficient, friendly and helpful. I loved their service so much I have chosen to rent with Harringtons again. Faultless 😊
See All Reviews
js_loader
<
Get in Touch

Send a message to a member of our team and we'll be happy to answer your questions!

Send a Message

Register for Property Alerts

Let us know what you're looking for and we'll email you with matching properties when they become available.

Make an Enquiry

Please complete the form below and a member of our team will be in touch shortly.